The Government added that on a somatic level the applicant had been given the necessary medical treatment: consultation with a lung specialist and an ophthalmologist in 2007, dental extractions and consultation

No observations had been made in respect of the applicant’s pulse, heart rate, pupils, lungs, abdomen, visible injuries (such as bruises or wounds) because, as it was noted, he had refused to have a physical

    In May 2004 the applicant underwent a medical examination and was diagnosed with suspected tuberculosis of the left lung.

In July 1997 a private forensic report, commissioned by the civil party, concluded that in view of the total absence of burn residue in the judge’s lungs, he must already have been dead when his body caught

He examined her lungs, found that she suffered from asthma, with attendant chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and prescribed treatment with pills and inhalers.

    In April 2007 the applicant was diagnosed with liver cirrhosis and advanced cancer of the left kidney with metastasis in the lungs.

administration, the applicant also cut the veins on his right arm and, having found an electrode in premises where repair work was being carried out, thrust it in his right side in an attempt to reach the lungs

unreported but cited by the Government at the Commission hearing on 6 May 1988; Paris Court of Appeal, Indictment Division, judgment of 27 June 1984 previously cited and judgment of 31 October 1984, Li Siu Lung

    At 5.45 p.m. on 20 October 1998, Dr Hallet noted that the first applicant was “dying from his lung disease”. 22.

The screening procedures currently employed (i.e. fluorographic examination of the lung fields on entry to prison and at six monthly intervals) are effective in detecting cases of active pulmonary tuberculosis

At 5.45 p.m. on 20   October 1998 Dr   Hallett noted that the first applicant “is dying from his lung disease”.

He claimed that on the latest occasion, in March 1999, the applicant had made a lunge at him. In P.N.'s view, the applicant had not made any positive progress since 10 October 1996, the date of P.N.'

The examination revealed no lung problems. 39.

    On 14 May 2004 the applicant underwent a chest and lung examination. In his report the doctor noted, in particular, old fractures of ten ribs and pulmonary fibrosis.

    On 30 March 2003, 27 August 2004, 24 February, 23 August and 14   December 2005 the applicant underwent X-ray examinations of his lungs and heart, which revealed no problems. 65.

In February 2003 he underwent a lung X-ray which revealed that he was suffering from tuberculosis (TB).

In addition, the applicant was suffering from tuberculosis of the 8 th and 9 th thoracic vertebrae and the lower part of the left lung, accompanied with breathing deficiency and secondary myocardiodystrophy

His lungs were checked and abdomen palpated. Upon palpation, the left side of his abdomen caused him pain, while the right side caused only light pain.

In July 1997 a private forensic report, commissioned by the civil party, concluded that in view of the total absence of burn residue in the judge’s lungs, he must already have been dead when his body caught